Substack vs Beehiiv vs Kit (ConvertKit): Which Newsletter Platform Is Best?

Share This Post

5/5 - (1 vote)

Choosing the right newsletter platform can feel a bit like choosing a laptop. They all send emails, but once you look closer, the differences start to matter.

🚀 Jump to

Substack, beehiiv, and Kit, formerly known as ConvertKit, all help creators build an email audience. However, they take different approaches to publishing, audience growth, automation, analytics, and monetization.

Substack focuses heavily on publishing and paid subscriptions. Beehiiv positions itself as a newsletter platform built around growth and monetization. Kit takes a more email-marketing-focused approach, with automation, segmentation, digital products, and creator-focused business tools.

So, in the Substack vs Beehiiv vs Kit debate, which one should you choose?

The short answer is:

Substack is excellent for writers who want a simple publishing platform and paid subscriptions.
beehiiv is a strong choice for newsletter businesses focused on audience growth, analytics, sponsorships, and monetization.
Kit is better suited to creators who want advanced email marketing, automation, segmentation, and the ability to sell products or subscriptions.

Let’s compare them properly.

Substack vs Beehiiv vs Kit: Quick Comparison

Feature	Substack	beehiiv	Kit
Best for	Writers and publishers	Newsletter businesses and media creators	Creators and email-first businesses
Free option	Yes	Yes	Yes
Paid subscriptions	Yes	Yes	Yes
Platform fee on paid subscriptions	10%	0% platform fee	Transaction fees apply
Email automation	Limited compared with Kit	Available on paid Scale plan	Strong automation tools
Audience segmentation	Basic compared with dedicated email platforms	Available	Strong
Newsletter analytics	Yes	Strong analytics	Strong, with advanced reporting on Pro
Ad monetization	Not its main focus	Strong	Available through creator-focused tools
Digital products	Limited	Yes	Yes
Creator recommendations	Yes	Yes	Yes
Best for writers	Excellent	Very good	Good
Best for email marketing	Good	Very good	Excellent
Best for automation	Basic	Good	Excellent

The exact pricing and feature availability can change, so always check the official pricing pages before making a final decision. At the time of writing, the platforms differ significantly in how they charge creators and where they place their strongest features.

Substack vs Beehiiv Pricing: Which Is Cheaper?

Pricing is one of the biggest questions when comparing Substack vs Beehiiv pricing, Beehiiv vs Kit pricing, and Substack vs Kit pricing.

But “cheapest” depends on what you need.

Substack Pricing

Substack lets creators publish for free, regardless of subscriber count. However, if you enable paid subscriptions, Substack takes 10% of each paid transaction. Stripe processing and billing fees also apply.

That makes Substack attractive if you want to start without a monthly software bill.

The trade-off becomes more noticeable as paid subscription revenue grows.

For example, if your paid newsletter generates $5,000 in subscription revenue, a 10% platform fee means $500 goes to Substack before Stripe-related fees.

That’s why the Substack fees vs Beehiiv comparison becomes more important as your business grows.

beehiiv Pricing

beehiiv currently offers a free Launch plan with up to 2,500 subscribers, unlimited email sends, newsletters, websites, podcasts, campaign analytics, and its Recommendation Network.

Its paid Scale plan starts at $43 per month on the pricing page we checked and adds features such as email automations, advanced website analytics, digital products, monetization tools, and 0% platform fees on paid subscriptions. Pricing varies by subscriber tier and billing choice.

For creators who make significant revenue from paid subscriptions, the 0% platform fee can make beehiiv financially attractive compared with Substack.

Kit Pricing

Kit offers a free Newsletter plan, with its current pricing information showing up to 10,000 active subscribers, unlimited broadcasts, landing pages, forms, digital products and subscriptions, plus limited automation functionality. Its paid Creator and Pro plans unlock more advanced automation, integrations, reporting, and other features.

Kit’s paid plans are designed more around email marketing and creator businesses than simply publishing a newsletter.

If you’re asking which newsletter platform is cheapest, there isn’t one universal winner.

Substack can be the cheapest way to start publishing because there is no monthly platform fee. But its 10% fee on paid subscriptions can become expensive as revenue increases.

beehiiv can make more financial sense for a growing paid newsletter because it charges 0% platform fees on paid subscriptions, although you still have the cost of your selected plan and payment processing.

Kit can be attractive for creators who need sophisticated email marketing and automation, particularly if they also sell digital products, subscriptions, or other offers.

In other words, don’t compare only the monthly price. Compare what you pay, what you earn, and what tools you actually need.

Substack vs Beehiiv Features

The biggest difference in the Substack vs Beehiiv features comparison is the philosophy behind each platform.

Substack feels more like a publishing network built around newsletters.

beehiiv feels more like a newsletter business platform built around growth.

Substack gives writers a straightforward way to publish posts, build free and paid audiences, and participate in its wider ecosystem. Its Notes feature also gives creators a place to share short-form content and interact with the broader Substack network. (Substack)

beehiiv puts more emphasis on growth infrastructure. Its platform includes newsletters, websites, podcasts, recommendations, analytics, monetization, and other publishing tools. (Beehiiv)

If your main goal is “I want to write and build a paid readership,” Substack is very compelling.

If your goal is “I want to build a newsletter business,” beehiiv deserves serious consideration.

Beehiiv vs Kit Features

The Beehiiv vs Kit features comparison is particularly interesting because both platforms target creators, but they lean in different directions.

beehiiv focuses heavily on newsletter growth, publishing, analytics, monetization, and media-style businesses.

Kit focuses more heavily on the relationship between email, audience segmentation, automation, and creator commerce.

Kit provides tagging and segmentation, visual automations, email sequences, integrations, recommendations, and tools for selling digital products and subscriptions. (Kit)

So, if you want your newsletter to become the center of a broader creator business, Kit may offer the stronger email marketing foundation.

Substack vs Beehiiv Automation

This is where the Substack vs Beehiiv automation comparison starts to separate the platforms.

Substack is primarily designed around publishing newsletters and building a reader relationship. It isn’t built to compete directly with a dedicated marketing automation platform.

beehiiv offers email automations on its paid Scale plan, making it more suitable for publishers who want to create automated subscriber journeys while also running a newsletter business. (Beehiiv)

However, if automation is your number-one priority, Kit deserves a closer look.

Kit’s Visual Automations can react to subscriber actions and move people through different paths based on behavior, tags, purchases, and other conditions. (Kit Help Center)

For creators asking which newsletter platform has the best automation, my pick is Kit.

beehiiv is a strong middle ground for newsletter operators.

Substack is the simplest option if you don’t need complex automated funnels.

Substack vs Beehiiv Email Marketing

The Substack vs Beehiiv email marketing comparison comes down to how much control you want over your subscriber journey.

Substack keeps the process simple. You publish, readers subscribe, and you can offer free or paid content.

beehiiv gives newsletter operators more growth-oriented tools, including audience recommendations, analytics, websites, and monetization features.

Kit goes further into traditional creator email marketing with segmentation, personalization, automations, and integrations. Its platform is built to help creators use email as an ongoing business channel rather than only as a publishing outlet. (Kit)

For a simple newsletter, Substack works.

For a growing publication, beehiiv is compelling.

For a creator business powered by email, Kit may be the better fit.

Substack vs Beehiiv Monetization

The Substack vs Beehiiv monetization debate is one of the strongest reasons creators compare these platforms.

Substack is particularly strong for paid subscriptions. You can offer free and paid plans, including monthly and annual options, and readers can subscribe directly to your publication. (Substack)

beehiiv takes a broader approach to monetization.

Its monetization tools include paid subscriptions, advertising, digital products, and recommendations. The company states that it takes 0% of paid subscription revenue, while payment processing fees still apply. (Beehiiv)

This gives beehiiv an advantage for creators who want several revenue streams.

For a writer who wants to launch a paid publication quickly, Substack remains a very strong choice.

For a publisher who wants paid subscriptions alongside ads, sponsorships, and other revenue opportunities, beehiiv may be more attractive.

For a creator selling a newsletter alongside digital products or other offers, Kit is worth considering. Kit supports paid newsletters and subscription products, with transaction fees depending on the product and payment setup. (Kit Help Center)

If you’re a journalist, author, columnist, independent writer, or simply someone who has more opinions than your group chat can handle, Substack is probably the easiest choice.

Its publishing-first experience makes it simple to focus on writing and building a readership.

Substack also has a built-in network through features such as Notes and recommendations, which can help creators participate in the wider ecosystem. (Substack)

Winner: Substack

The answer depends on what you mean by “creator.”

If you’re primarily a writer, choose Substack.

If you’re building a media newsletter with strong growth and monetization goals, choose beehiiv.

If you’re building a creator business around email, products, funnels, and automation, choose Kit.

For the broader category of best newsletter platform for creators, I would give the overall edge to Kit for business-focused creators and beehiiv for newsletter-focused creators.

Entrepreneurs often need more than a weekly email.

They may need lead magnets, landing pages, segmentation, automated sequences, product sales, and integrations.

That makes Kit a strong choice for entrepreneurs and content creators who want email to support a wider business.

beehiiv can be a better fit when the newsletter itself is the business, particularly for publishers focused on growth, audience analytics, advertising, and paid subscriptions.

Substack makes more sense when the core product is the publication and paid reader relationship.

If sponsorships are central to your business model, beehiiv has a clear advantage in this comparison.

Its monetization system includes an advertising network and sponsorship-focused tools, with ad performance reporting built into the platform. (Beehiiv)

Kit also offers creator-focused sponsorship opportunities and other monetization options. (Kit)

Substack is better known for paid subscriptions than for being an advertising-first newsletter platform.

Winner for sponsorship-focused newsletters: beehiiv

Substack vs Beehiiv Analytics

The Substack vs Beehiiv analytics comparison is another area where beehiiv stands out.

Substack provides creators with useful publication and audience data, but beehiiv places analytics much closer to the center of its product strategy.

Its plans include campaign analytics, while higher tiers add more advanced website analytics and other reporting capabilities. (Beehiiv)

Kit also provides reporting, with advanced deliverability reporting, engagement scoring, and an Insights dashboard available on its Pro plan. (Kit Help Center)

For newsletter operators who care deeply about growth measurement, beehiiv is my pick.

For creators who want to understand email engagement, audience behavior, and business performance across an email-driven business, Kit is also very strong.

Is Substack Better Than Beehiiv?

Substack is better than beehiiv if your priority is writing, publishing, and building a paid reader community with minimal setup.

beehiiv is better than Substack if you want more growth, analytics, monetization, sponsorship, and newsletter-business features.

So, is Substack better than Beehiiv?

For writers, often yes.

For newsletter entrepreneurs, often no.

Is Beehiiv Better Than Kit?

beehiiv is better than Kit if your primary business revolves around a newsletter publication and you want strong growth and monetization features.

Kit is better than beehiiv if you want advanced email automation, segmentation, creator commerce, and a broader email marketing system.

Think of it this way:

beehiiv asks: How do we grow and monetize this newsletter?

Kit asks: How do we use email to grow and monetize this creator business?

That’s a small wording difference with a fairly big strategic difference.

Is Kit Better Than Beehiiv?

If you’re building automated email funnels, selling products, managing audience segments, or connecting multiple creator tools, Kit may be better than beehiiv.

Kit’s Visual Automations can create subscriber journeys based on actions and conditions, while its App Store connects creators with a wide range of external tools. (Kit)

However, if your main goal is to build a newsletter publication with strong analytics, advertising, and growth tools, beehiiv may be the better choice.

Should I Use Substack or Beehiiv?

Choose Substack if:

You are primarily a writer.
You want to launch quickly.
Paid subscriptions are your main monetization strategy.
You don’t need complex email automation.
You like being part of a publishing network.

Choose beehiiv if:

Your newsletter is becoming a serious business.
You care about audience growth and analytics.
You want sponsorship and advertising options.
You want paid subscriptions without a platform revenue cut.
You want digital products and multiple monetization channels.

Should I Use Beehiiv or Kit?

Choose beehiiv if your newsletter is the product.

Choose Kit if your newsletter is part of the product.

That one sentence probably explains the difference better than a 47-row comparison table ever could.

beehiiv is particularly attractive for newsletter publishers, media brands, and creators who want growth and monetization tools.

Kit is particularly attractive for creators, entrepreneurs, authors, educators, and businesses that want email automation and audience management at the center of their strategy.

Should I Switch From Substack to Beehiiv?

You may want to consider switching from Substack to beehiiv if your newsletter has grown beyond simple publishing and you now need better analytics, monetization options, audience growth systems, or more control over your newsletter business.

However, switching platforms takes work.

Before moving, compare your current subscriber workflow, paid subscriptions, integrations, content archive, domain setup, and automation requirements.

Don’t migrate just because another platform has a shinier landing page. Migrate because your current platform is holding your business back.

Should I Switch From ConvertKit to Beehiiv?

If you’re currently using ConvertKit, now branded as Kit, the decision depends on your priorities.

If you rely heavily on automation, segmentation, integrations, and creator commerce, Kit may still be the better fit.

If your newsletter has evolved into a media-style publication and you care more about newsletter growth, advertising, sponsorships, analytics, and paid subscriptions, beehiiv could make more sense.

The ConvertKit vs Beehiiv vs Substack comparison is therefore less about which platform is “best” and more about which business model you’re building.

Final Verdict: Substack vs Beehiiv vs Kit

There is no single winner in the Substack vs Beehiiv vs Kit comparison.

Each platform solves a slightly different problem.

Choose Substack for writing and paid readership.

It is the simplest choice for writers who want to publish consistently and monetize through paid subscriptions.

It is a strong option for publishers and creators who want analytics, recommendations, sponsorships, advertising, paid subscriptions, and digital products in one newsletter-focused ecosystem.

Choose Kit for email marketing and creator businesses.

It stands out when automation, segmentation, integrations, digital products, and creator-focused email marketing matter most.

My overall recommendation:

Best newsletter platform for writers: Substack
Best newsletter platform for paid subscriptions: Substack for simplicity; beehiiv for a broader monetization strategy
Best newsletter platform for sponsorships: beehiiv
Best newsletter platform for email automation: Kit
Best newsletter platform for creators: Kit for business-focused creators
Best newsletter platform for newsletter businesses: beehiiv
Best platform to start a simple newsletter: Substack
Best Substack alternative: beehiiv for publishing-focused users; Kit for email-marketing-focused creators

Ultimately, the best platform is the one that matches how you plan to make money.

If you’re selling your writing, start with Substack.

If you’re building a newsletter business, look closely at beehiiv.

If you’re building a business powered by email, Kit is likely the strongest fit.

The smartest choice isn’t the platform with the longest feature list. It’s the one you’ll actually use consistently, grow with, and still like when your subscriber count has more commas than your patience.

Sources: Pricing and feature details in this comparison were checked against the official documentation and pricing pages of Substack, beehiiv, and Kit, including their current information on subscription fees, plans, automation, analytics, and monetization.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best